Skip to main content
Cinnamon Roll*

Desserts in Mt Vernon

Pies, cakes, and ice cream make up the desserts at Southside Diner in Mt Vernon, OH, with pickup available for your order.

Order online

Cakes

Pumpkin Roll*

$2.99+

Pumpkin cake rolled around a creamy filling comes in one to three pieces.

“I love this restaurant so much. I don't live oin Mt Vernon anymore, but I jump at the opportunity to come to Southside every time I come back. Wonderful food and awesome fresh made deserts not available anywhere else.”

Apple Cake w/Ice Cream*

$5.99

Apple cake served with ice cream as a two-part dessert.

“Southside diner has had a place in my heart forever. My mother used to take me there when she was alive🥺😥 and I grew up on no welfare but every month she would take me LOL they have the best food country fried steaks the bomb! They got good desserts friendly help drinks they got the works. So please go there and have yourself a meal. If you ain't never been there you're in for a treat!!”

Fruit Pies

Pecan Pie*

$4.99

Pecan pie is a sweet dessert baked with pecans in a pastry crust.

“We really enjoyed our dinner after church. It was very busy but we had great service and delicious food. Highly recommend. The turkey open faced sandwich was delicious along with the fish and chips and Cole slaw were excellent and the 4 meat omelet was great. I also recommend the butterscotch pie! It was a huge slice. We also buy whole pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas that taste homemade.”

Cream Pies

Pumpkin Pie*

$4.99

Pumpkin custard pie with an optional change to Turtle style.

“Was pleasantly suprised by this establishment. Everyone was very nice and the food was excellent. If you leave here still hungry it wasn't because they give small servings, the servings were huge! The dessert menu had a large selection that sounded incredibly good. Will definitely go again next time we are in Mt. Vernon. Thanks for the great meal.”

Ice Cream

Kids Sundae*

$2.99

A kid-sized ice cream sundae with several flavor choices.

“Really enjoy eating there have been several times in the month since we found this place. Each time the meal has been very good. The atmosphere and service are great. Place has good food for a fair price so gets pretty busy during meal times. Has daily specials and the deserts are delicious. Get the cheese cake or creme pies. Its now a regular stop for us when in Mt Vernon.”

Peach Pie*

Made with Care at Southside Diner

Southside Diner serves desserts with peach and cherry pies, coconut cream pie, and peanut butter cup pie. You'll also find cinnamon rolls and apple cake paired with ice cream alongside the pies.

Cheese Cake comes with fruit choices such as fresh strawberries or cherry topping. Pumpkin Roll* is available in one or three pieces, while Banana Split (3 scoop)* offers chocolate or vanilla ice cream.

Order from Southside Diner in Mt Vernon, OH, with pickup, dine-in, and delivery available. Ice Cream* offers one or two scoops in flavors such as black raspberry, orange pineapple, and Oreo.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular desserts options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Peanut Butter Cup Pie* — This cream pie brings together peanut butter and chocolate, echoing the classic combination found in peanut butter cups.
  • Cinnamon Roll* — This sweet roll is dough wrapped around cinnamon in a spiral, served as a breakfast pastry.
  • Peach Pie* — Sweet peach filling sits inside a pie crust; the menu identifies it as a fruit pie without listing extra toppings.
  • Apple Pie* — Tender apple filling sits inside a pie crust; the menu identifies it as a fruit pie without listing extra toppings.
  • Pecan Pie* — This traditional pie combines pecans and sweet filling inside a baked pastry crust for dessert.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for desserts throughout the Mt Vernon area. Order your desserts online for convenient pickup or delivery.